Apple removes data security feature in the UK after government influence
We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission which is paid directly to our Australia-based writers, editors, and support staff. Thank you for your support!
Apple Discontinues Advanced Data Protection in the UK Due to Government Pressure
Quick Overview
- Apple has ceased the Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature in the UK.
- ADP offered end-to-end encryption for iCloud backups, ensuring only users had access to their data.
- This action follows governmental pressure under the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act of 2016.
- Current ADP users will be alerted to deactivate the feature.
- Security professionals caution that this could diminish data privacy and escalate cyber threat risks.
- Australia has similar regulations and might follow the UK’s footsteps in demanding access to encrypted data.
What is Apple’s Advanced Data Protection?
Improved Privacy for iCloud Users
Apple rolled out Advanced Data Protection (ADP) in 2022 to enhance end-to-end encryption for iCloud backups. This ensured that even Apple could not retrieve data stored in iCloud, such as messages, photos, and files. The initiative was hailed as a crucial advancement in consumer data safety.
Government Concerns
Law enforcement agencies globally have historically opposed robust encryption, claiming it hinders their ability to investigate criminal activities. The UK’s Investigatory Powers Act permits officials to issue Technical Capability Notices (TCNs), obligating companies to aid in data access. Apple’s choice to remove ADP seems to align with these stipulations.
Consequences for UK Users
Less Privacy and Security
With the removal of ADP, iCloud backups in the UK will lack the highest encryption standards. This implies that Apple could potentially access and hand over user data to authorities if legally demanded. Security experts caution that weakening encryption elevates the risk of cyber threats and unauthorized access.
Effects on Current Users
Although Apple cannot deactivate ADP for those who have previously enabled it, users will be prompted to switch it off. New attempts to activate it will result in an error notification.
Could Australia Follow the Same Path?
Australia’s Encryption Regulations
Australia possesses comparable legislation under the Telecommunications and Other Legislation Amendment (Assistance and Access) Act 2018, allowing authorities to request access to encrypted communications. Experts propose that Australia might issue a similar order to Apple, necessitating compliance.
Potential Effects on Australian Users
If Australia adopts the UK’s approach, local Apple users may also lose access to ADP. This raises alarms about government overreach and the future of consumer privacy in Australia.
Industry Responses and Future Perspectives
Tech and Privacy Advocates Speak Out
Cybersecurity experts and privacy advocates have condemned Apple’s decision. Meredith Whittaker, president of Signal, described the move as “technically illiterate” and warned it could be detrimental to the UK’s tech sector. Other experts contend that compromising encryption in one country may set a dangerous precedent globally.
What’s Next for Apple?
Apple has repeatedly resisted governmental attempts to undermine encryption, previously rebuffing the US government’s request to unlock an iPhone in 2016. However, compliance with UK regulations indicates that Apple may confront similar demands in other areas.
Conclusion
Apple’s discontinuation of Advanced Data Protection in the UK signifies a notable shift in the ongoing struggle between privacy advocates and government entities. While law enforcement makes a case for necessary access to encrypted information, cybersecurity experts highlight the dangers associated with reducing encryption strength. Given Australia’s parallel laws, speculation grows regarding whether the country may mirror the UK’s actions. This development raises significant concerns about the global future of digital privacy and security.
Common Questions
Q: What is Apple’s Advanced Data Protection (ADP)?
A: ADP is a voluntary security feature that extends end-to-end encryption to iCloud backups, ensuring no one—including Apple—can access the stored data.
Q: Why did Apple eliminate ADP in the UK?
A: Apple is believed to have complied with the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act, which permits the government to mandate companies to assist in accessing data.
Q: How does this change affect UK users?
A: New users can no longer enable ADP, and current users will be prompted to turn off the feature, making their iCloud backups less secure.
Q: Will this decision influence Australia?
A: Experts suggest that Australia may follow the UK’s lead due to its similar encryption laws, which could result in the removal of ADP there as well.
Q: Can users in the UK still secure their data?
A: Yes, data stored directly on Apple devices remains protected. However, iCloud backups will no longer feature end-to-end encryption.
Q: Could this create a precedent for other nations?
A: Yes. If additional governments demand similar access, Apple may be compelled to reduce encryption in more regions.
Q: What are the implications of removing ADP?
A: Lowering encryption standards increases the likelihood of cyberattacks, unauthorized data access, and potential governmental overreach.
Q: Are there options for UK users seeking encryption?
A: Users can look into alternative services like Signal or ProtonMail, which provide end-to-end encryption for messaging and email.
